Visiting Linz

Lately I had the pleasure of visiting Linz, Armin Biere’s workplace, where I gave a quick talk on SAT solver architectures. To me, it was really interesting to think through that presentation — not because it was entirely new or exciting, but because it recapped on many issues that have been bothering me lately. Namely, that it’s difficult to make a really versatile SAT solver, because the low-level choices that must be made (e.g. watchlist scheme) determines so many things when one must make higher-level architectural decisions such as clause sharing or even something as simple as hyper-binary resolution. As for this latter, thanks to Armin Biere’s thoughts I have finally managed to realise why my hyper-binary resolution was so slow: I lately took the decision not to fully propagate binary clauses before propagating normal (i.e. larger) clauses, which meant that doing hyper-binary resolution was much slower as I had to re-calculate the binary graph. The fact of not fully propagating binary clauses before normal clauses seemed also to influence my much higher-level choice of using cached implications, as they (intuitively, and also in practice) help much more if binary clauses are not fully propagated before normal clauses. This latter influence is interesting to think through, as something this trivial shouldn’t — at least in principle — influence such a high-level decision.

Also thanks to Armin Biere, I have managed to grasp a better understanding of lingeling and its superior watchlist scheme. Some of the architectural elements of lingeling’s watchlist scheme are really interesting, and when they get published I will definitely port some of them to CryptoMiniSat. It seems to use much less space, and stores information in a more cache-friendly manner, aiding the processor in its job. A related, interesting pointer that I have learnt is this paper that originally introduced blocking literals, but also talks about a range of other ideas that can help. All in all, it was great to visit Linz and the group of Armin Biere, as I have managed to learn a lot from him and his colleagues.